A Holly Jolly Ever After by Sierra Simone and Julie Murphy

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you

A Holly Jolly Ever After delivers another dose of holiday rom-com charm, courtesy of the dynamic duo Sierra Simone and Julie Murphy. Compared to its predecessor, A Merry Little Meet Cute, this book felt faster-paced and slightly less cheesy, which made for a refreshing and enjoyable read. It’s clear that the authors have grown in their collaboration, showcasing improvements in pacing, writing style, and overall plot depth. While it retains the festive spirit and humor that made the first book memorable, this sequel stands out for its more grounded and polished storytelling.

A Fresh Take on Familiar Tropes

The story uses the surprise pregnancy trope, which is a familiar staple in romance but can often feel overdone or clichéd. However, I was pleasantly surprised by how well it was handled here. Winnie’s pregnancy didn’t feel like a convenient plot device meant to force her relationship with Kallum. Instead, the authors allowed her to maintain her independence and agency throughout the story. Winnie’s decisions and actions were never dictated by her circumstances, and I appreciated that her relationship with Kallum felt like a partnership rather than one built on obligation or necessity.

Winnie’s “good girl gone bad” storyline was another intriguing aspect of the book. It was exciting to see her embrace a new lifestyle and step out of her comfort zone, but I couldn’t help feeling that the authors could have leaned more heavily into her straight-laced background. The book hints at her upbringing in a rigid “purity culture” environment, but her transition to a freer, more uninhibited version of herself felt a bit rushed. If she had truly been as devoted to her conservative values as implied, her quick comfort with such a drastically different way of life seemed inconsistent. Exploring this transformation in greater depth would have added more realism and complexity to her character arc, making her journey even more impactful.

Missed Opportunities for Drama

One area where the book fell slightly short was in its use of Winnie’s ex-husband. Given the backstory we’re provided about their tumultuous relationship, it’s surprising that he only appeared a couple of times throughout the story. His minimal involvement didn’t align with the image the authors painted early on—a domineering and toxic figure whose presence loomed large in Winnie’s past. This was a missed opportunity to add more tension and drama to the plot. A more active role for him could have created additional obstacles for Winnie and Kallum to overcome, making their eventual happy ending even more satisfying.

For instance, the ex-husband could have been used to challenge Winnie’s newfound independence or create a conflict that tested Kallum’s commitment to her. Instead, his brief appearances felt almost incidental, which undermined the stakes of the story. Adding more depth to his character and involvement in the plot could have enriched the narrative and added a layer of complexity that would resonate with readers.

Holiday Rom-Com Charm

That said, the holiday rom-com elements were once again spot-on. The book strikes a balance between cheesiness and predictability, evoking the cozy, feel-good vibe of a Hallmark Christmas movie. Unlike A Merry Little Meet Cute, which leaned heavily into over-the-top humor, this installment dialed it back just enough to feel more grounded. This balance was a relief and made the story more enjoyable for me.

The festive setting plays a significant role in the story’s charm, immersing readers in the magic of the holiday season. From snow-covered streets to twinkling lights, the attention to detail in creating a winter wonderland atmosphere is delightful. The humor, heart, and festive cheer shine through in every chapter, making this book an ideal read for curling up by the fire with a cup of hot cocoa. Whether it’s the quirky supporting characters or the delightfully awkward situations Winnie and Kallum find themselves in, the book is packed with moments that will make you smile and laugh.

Growth as a Writing Duo

One of the most impressive aspects of A Holly Jolly Ever After is how it demonstrates Sierra Simone and Julie Murphy’s growth as a writing duo. Their humor and heart remain consistent, but the story’s flow and structure feel more polished compared to A Merry Little Meet Cute. The faster pace made the book hard to put down, while the deeper character development added layers to the narrative that weren’t as prominent in their earlier collaboration.

The authors also did a commendable job balancing humor with emotional depth. While the book retains its lighthearted tone, there are moments of genuine vulnerability and introspection that add weight to the story. This balance makes the characters’ journeys feel more authentic and relatable, showcasing the authors’ ability to evolve and refine their storytelling.

My Rating Breakdown:

• Plot: 4/5 – The story was engaging and fun, though some elements (like the ex-husband) felt underdeveloped.
• Characters: 4/5 – Winnie and Kallum were entertaining leads, but Winnie’s transformation felt a bit rushed.
• Writing Style: 5/5 – The authors’ humor and heart shine through, with clear growth in their collaboration.
• Themes and Messages: 4/5 – Themes of independence and love were well-handled, but some tropes felt slightly overdone.
• Pacing and Structure: 5/5 – The faster pace and smoother story flow made this book easy to enjoy.
• Personal Enjoyment: 4/5 – A delightful holiday read, though it didn’t quite leave the lasting impression of the first book.

Total Score: 26/30

Average Score: 4.33/5

Final Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4 stars)

Final Thoughts

A Holly Jolly Ever After is a delightful addition to the holiday rom-com genre, offering plenty of humor, heart, and festive cheer. While it has its flaws, including some underutilized characters and rushed character arcs, the book’s strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. Winnie and Kallum’s romance is charming and fun, making it easy to root for their happy ending.

If you’re a fan of holiday-themed romances or loved A Merry Little Meet Cute, this book is definitely worth picking up. Sierra Simone and Julie Murphy have proven that their collaboration only gets better with time, and I’m excited to see what they come up with next. With its cozy holiday vibes and heartfelt romance, A Holly Jolly Ever After is sure to bring a smile to your face and warmth to your heart during the festive season.

---